The Hall of Fame falls short again: Negreanu and Hellmuth point fingers at the system – CodigoPoker

The Hall of Fame falls short again: Negreanu and Hellmuth point fingers at the system - CodigoPoker
El Salón de la Fama vuelve a quedar en deuda: Negreanu y Hellmuth apuntan contra el sistema

Changing the rules so that everything ends up practically the same. That is the paradox left by the 2026 Poker Hall of Fame election, whose new voting system was born with a fairly clear mission: to open the door for more than one figure to enter during the same year. However, from a generation loaded with candidates, only Jason Koon

United States
managed to surpass the necessary threshold.

The list included names such as Shaun Deeb

United States
, Scott Seiver
United States
, Isaac Haxton
United States
and Isai Scheinberg
Israel
, among others. For many, there were enough arguments to have two or even three new members. But the math said otherwise and now two heavyweights like Daniel Negreanu
United States
and Phil Hellmuth
United States
agree, something that already constitutes news by itself, that the system needs another surgery.

Negreanu was categorical: “The problem was the system itself.” His proposal for 2027 consists of forcing each Hall of Fame member to choose three candidates through a ranking. The first would receive five points, the second three, and the third two. The two highest scores would enter automatically, even leaving open the possibility of a third if it reaches a certain threshold.

Jason Koon

Jason Koon With His Award.

The Canadian also pointed to another weakness: voters were not required to use all their votes. Phil Ivey

United States
, for example, only supported Koon. Also, Negreanu believes some electors might not know the merits of all candidates sufficiently and proposes that each nominee can formally present their resume.

Read more Arrived at the last minute and ended up champion: Vaskaboinikau conquers Onyx — CodigoPoker

Hellmuth, meanwhile, put names on the table. For the Poker Brat, Deeb and Seiver should be in. Although he questioned the huge volume of tournaments Deeb plays — and how that can influence the perception of his bracelets — he assured that his merits are enough. About Seiver he was even more forceful: he highlighted his two decades competing in some of the biggest games in the world.

The discussion leaves an uncomfortable conclusion. The Hall of Fame wanted to widen the door, but barely managed to move it a few centimeters.

And while candidates with enormous careers continue accumulating outside, the question remains the same: is it really that hard to choose the best or has the Poker Hall of Fame still not found a fair way to do it?

Read more The WSOP returns to the tables… online: 33 bracelets and a Main Event with US$25 million guaranteed —

Source: Poker.org

Translated from

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *